The Saint Mary’s Church that existed now was completed in 1881 and the rectory in 1888. The older church was made in 1844 on King Street. It was a mission church of the Saint Matthew Church in Springfield/Chicopee and then the Holy Name Church in Chicopee.
| pastor | starts | ends | burial |
| Patrick Moyce | 1866 | 1872 | FINDAGRAVE |
| Michael Barry | 1872 | 1889 | FINDAGRAVE |
| John Kenny | 1889 | 1917 | FINDAGRAVE |
| Thomas Cummings | 1917 | 1961 | FINDAGRAVE |
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| John T. MacPherson | 1967 | 1973 | FINDAGRAVE |
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
| FINDAGRAVE | |||
Thomas Cummings served for 44 years at the church as pastor.
